As detective Gary Nephew, we’re expected to search an isolated estate, examine evidence and work out what happened to the Juniper family without fighting our way through the mystery. Brazilian studio BlackHawk Games first released Beyond the Evil in 2023, but its new Director’s Cut gave the team a chance to revisit some of the ideas that hadn’t worked as well as they hoped. We spoke with developer Luís F. Beani about creating fear through investigation, rethinking old puzzles and learning from the people who played the original.
Fear Without a Weapon
Beani and his team wanted the uncertainty to come from the investigation itself, rather than depending on an enemy to attack us every few minutes.
Most of the newer investigation titles focus on Combat, Stealth and Predictable Jumpscares. Knowing that, we thought about going back to the basics and investing into tension through the environments and soundtracks.

That approach puts plenty of pressure on the estate’s rooms and the things scattered around them. We can examine hundreds of objects, but finding something interesting shouldn’t necessarily mean we’re holding the next piece of a puzzle.
When you look into video game environments, there’s always at least one item that brings the curiosity of the player even if it’s a texture or particle. To make a balance between the importance of progressive items and non-progressive items, we made the “curious items” from the game either being achievements or story related information (Character story/Past of the scene).

Returning to the Crime Scene
Coming back to a game three years after its original release meant confronting parts of the experience that players had struggled with. In particular, the puzzles had developed a habit of feeling rather familiar, and not necessarily in a good way.
The main complaints of the Legacy Version of Beyond The Evil (2023) were that most of the presented puzzles looked and played the same (box with codes and a key inside). So after designing new puzzles on Dawn Of Fear (2027) and looking into newer releases/old titles for inspiration, we thought about improving all the unnecessary puzzles into new ideas/scenes.
Changing the puzzles was only part of the work. Chapter 5 also needed a more convincing pursuer, because the old version of Matthew Juniper had a rather unfortunate habit of losing track of the person he was supposed to be chasing.
The old AI system was too simple for the safe puzzle in Chapter 5. Matthew didn’t go to the rooms and it was too easy to forget the player. We reworked the methods by adding hiding spots and a camera system to increase the player’s knowledge of the playthrough while keeping the same tension with footsteps and a jumpscare sound when detected.

How Much Should a Detective Be Told?
There’s another difficult decision in a mystery like this: how much information should reach Gary directly, and how much should remain for us to discover? His partner Lukas Smith has an important part to play in that balance, although Beani’s explanation also reveals a major piece of the story.
Story spoiler warning: The following answer reveals a major character identity.
All information provided from Lukas (aka Matthew Juniper’s new name) were all planned to destinate Gary to the Masked Man’s Mansion. The rest of them (hidden through notes/scenarios) were destined to the players to create their own theory.
Learning from the First Investigation
For all the changes to puzzles, clues and enemy behaviour, Beani’s clearest advice to other developers is much simpler. The team had the benefit of seeing how people responded to the original release, rather than having to guess which ideas were working.
The best lesson we could give is: Listen and talk with your community! Game reviews, player interactions and gameplay videos are the best way to look at what could improve in your game.
Hearing Beani discuss the Director’s Cut, we’re especially interested in how the changes to puzzles and Chapter 5 affect that experience. Although if Matthew has become better at finding us, perhaps we should be a little less enthusiastic about going back inside.

Leave a Reply